← Writing / Mohit's World
A Decision That Looked Eccentric to Everyone Around Me
In 2019, I planted 1,200 banana trees on land my family owns. I live in a city, work in financial services, and spend most of my time thinking about markets and products. And yet, here I was, walking muddy rows of freshly turned earth, overseeing the planting of Cavendish saplings across a stretch of rural land that had mostly been sitting idle.
People thought it was a hobby. Some thought it was a midlife experiment. A few friends in finance thought it was mildly comic, “the markets guy is playing farmer.” What nobody expected, least of all me, was how much that project would teach me about the thing I spend my days thinking about: long-term investing.
The Input-Output Gap Is Long and Uncomfortable
When you plant a banana tree, you do not see a banana for about 9 to 12 months. During that entire period, you are putting in work. You water. You weed. You manage soil health. You worry about pests. You invest time, money, and attention into something that gives you absolutely nothing visible in return.
With 1,200 trees, the upfront costs are real and tangible. The returns are distant and theoretical. There is a long stretch in the middle where the rational part of your brain starts asking uncomfortable questions: is this actually going to work? Would it have been better to just leave the land as it was? What if something goes wrong in month 8 and all this effort comes to nothing?
I have felt that same discomfort before. Not in a banana plantation, but in a portfolio. The first two years of a long-term SIP feel like this. You are putting money in every month, watching markets be indifferent or actively hostile, and the account value looks discouraging. Nothing is happening, or so it seems.
But the plant is growing underground before you see it above ground. The roots are establishing. The trunk is thickening. The work is happening, just not where you can see it.
The Temptation to Quit Before Harvest
Month seven of the banana project, we had a pest problem on one section of the plantation. About 80 trees in one corner showed signs of disease. I had to make a call: treat aggressively, quarantine the section, or give up on that corner entirely.
I remember standing there thinking: this would be a perfectly rational moment to scale back. Cut the losses. Reduce the complexity. Who would blame me? The project was never proven yet. The returns were still months away.
I have seen this exact moment play out with investors during a market correction. They are 18 months into a SIP, the portfolio is down 15%, and the temptation to pause or exit is overwhelming. The investment has not proven itself yet. The discomfort is real. And stopping feels rational, even responsible.
We treated the disease. We lost about 40 trees in that corner. But 1,160 trees went on to bear fruit. Had I scaled back in month seven, I would have permanently reduced the harvest from a problem that turned out to be manageable.
Harvest Is Not a Single Moment, It Compounds Over Time
Here is something I did not fully appreciate before starting: a banana tree is not a one-time thing. Once a banana plant fruits and the bunch is harvested, the plant produces what is called a ratoon, a secondary stem that grows from the same rootstock and fruits again in another 8-10 months. And then another. And another. A well-maintained banana plant can produce for several years from a single planting.
You invest once. You wait. You get a return. And then, without investing again, you get another return from the same root system. And another.
I do not need to explain the compounding parallel. But I will say this: reading about compounding in a textbook is one thing. Watching a ratoon shoot emerge from a plant you planted in 2019 and knowing it will bear fruit again without any additional investment is viscerally different. It changes something in how the concept lands.
What Farming Teaches That Finance Books Cannot
Finance books can explain compounding mathematically. They can show you the curve, the formula, the thirty-year projections. What they cannot do is make you feel the patience required to live through the waiting period. That is a physical, embodied experience, and farming provides it in a way that spreadsheets simply do not.
When you are tending to plants, you cannot refresh a screen to check today’s value. There is no portfolio tracker. There is no daily NAV. There is just the work, the waiting, and eventually the harvest. That enforced patience is a feature, not a limitation. It is the thing that most long-term investors struggle to manufacture in a world of real-time market data.
I have thought about this often since starting the plantation: how much of the damage done to retail investor returns is caused not by bad stock picks, but by the inability to sit still through a long waiting period? Most people are not bad analysts. They are bad at waiting.
The Joys of Diversification, Jharkhand Edition
Interestingly, the banana project has also given me new intuitions about diversification and risk management. Early on, we planted primarily one variety in one section. When a specific pest hit that variety, the concentration hurt us. In subsequent planting, we mixed varieties and staggered the planting timelines, so harvests do not all come at once and risk is spread across biological difference.
This is not sophisticated portfolio theory. It is just common sense applied to agriculture. But common sense applied to agriculture is exactly the same common sense that applies to investment portfolios, and it was remarkable to me how the farming context made the logic feel more natural than any academic presentation of diversification I had encountered.
The Real Return on the Investment
The banana plantation is producing now. The financial returns are modest, this is not a venture-scale business, and I did not expect it to be. But the returns in thinking, in patience, in the quiet satisfaction of watching something you planted with your own hands grow and fruit and ratoon, those are harder to put on a spreadsheet.
I have started recommending, only half-jokingly, that every investor should try to grow something, anything, that takes more than a year to yield. Not because it will make them rich, but because the experience of maintaining patience through a long waiting period, without any feedback mechanism except the slow growth of the plant, is the most visceral teacher of long-term investment psychology I have found.
The finance textbooks are good. But the banana trees are better.
If you are thinking about the connection between patience and compounding in your own portfolio, you might find it useful to think through how long-term equity gains are taxed in India and why the 12-month holding threshold matters. The structure of the tax rules themselves is designed to reward the kind of waiting that farming has taught me.